BrownGirl Speaks
  • Home
  • Journal
  • Books
  • Community
  • About Me
  • Contact Me
As I lay Dying by William Faulkner 09/13/2009
3 Comments
 
Picture
This post should have been done days ago, but c'est la vie.  Without further ado...

I've read As I Lay Dying for a banned books challenge I wrote about here. Why has this Faulkner classic made it to the infamous banned/challenged book list? Banned-Books.com states: "In 1986, Graves County, Kentucky, the school board banned this book about a poor white family in the midst of crisis, from its high school English reading list because of 7 passages which made reference to God or abortion and used curse words such as "bastard," "goddam," and "son of a bitch." None of the board members had actually read the book."

Of course, this sounds almost absurd in 2009, but in 1932 when it was originally published, this was seen as gravely offensive. Apparently it was in 1986 as well, at least to one school.

This novel about a poor white southern family going through great lengths to bury their matriarch, Addie Bundren, was filled with so much pathos. The patriarch, Anse, wants to honor his wife's wishes to be buried in another town other than their own and get some new teeth. Their daughter, Dewey Dell, has gotten herself in "trouble" and spends much of the novel trying to find a pharmacist to help her get out of it. The four sons, Vardaman, Cash, Jewel, and Darl have a host of issues. Vardaman could be described as a simpleton and doesn't cope well with his mother's death. Cash is a bit passive and the constructor of his mother's coffin. Darl goes insane. And Jewel is the illegitimate son of Addie Bundren and a priest.

As the Classics often are hit or miss, this one was a near miss for me. I still can't quite put my finger on it. I think it's that I prefer livelier language, but that wouldn't have made sense in this novel. Hence the reason I say near miss. I do not like Faulkner's approach to dialect. Though he was a southerner, as am I, he did not seem to command white southerners dialect. And I know it varies from state to state and even from different corners of a state. On the positive, his employment of stream of consciousness was effortless. He also did well with emotional nuances which are most notable in the chapters where Dewey Dell speaks. She is actually vocal so sparsely that he relies on her subtle gestures to parlay emotion and it was effective. Overall, I think this is one of those books everyone should check out for themselves. And to stick it to those past or present who think it should be banned.

 


Comments

Thomas link
09/17/2009 6:50am

Oh, have I tried to get into Faulkner over the years. The closest I came to finishing one of his books was in grad school when he was on the syllabus.

Reply
BrownGirl
09/17/2009 9:29am

Thomas, I think Faulkner will go back to being only for scholastic endeavors.

Reply
Sheila DeChantal link
09/22/2009 1:21pm

This is an amazing review. I had no idea about the banning of this book. This sounds like one I would like to try knowing full well I may not get through it...

Reply

Comments are closed.
    Authors and publishers feel free to check out my review policy and contact me  regarding review requests.
    The Book Depository
    Picture

    My Amazon.com Wish List

    Picture

    Archives

    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010
    January 2010
    December 2009
    November 2009
    October 2009
    September 2009
    August 2009
    July 2009

    Categories

    All
    African Diaspora
    And The Word Was Spoken
    Asian Authors
    Author Interviews
    Banned Books
    Blog Tours
    Book Reviews
    Book Tours
    Bookish
    Challenges
    Diversity Roll Call
    Giveaways
    Guest Post
    Kid Lit
    Latino Authors
    Native American Authors
    Nonfiction
    Quirky Brown
    Reading Africa
    The Box Is Hot
    Women Writers
    Writing
    Ya Fiction


    Picture
    Sign Up
    Suggestion List
    First Quarter Reviews
    Second Quarter Reviews
    Third Quarter Reviews
    Read 17/12

    Picture
    Read 5/54
    Picture
    Read 5/8
    Read 2/5
    Picture
    Read 1/4
    2010 Social Justice Reading Challenge
    Read 0/12
    Picture
    Read 1/7
    Read 26/25

    Book Blogs

    A Striped Armchair
    Authors In Color
    Black Eyed Susans
    Book Blab
    Book On the Train
    Brown Paper
    Color Online
    For the Love of Books
    In Spring It Is The Dawn
    Kinna Reads
    Lotus Reads
    Love of Literature
    Notorious Spinks Talks
    Page247
    Reading In Color
    Reads4Pleasure
    Rhapsody In Books
    The Brown Bookshelf
    The Feminist Texican [Reads]
    The Happy Nappy Bookseller
    With Extra Pulp
    Worducopia

    Authors

    Chimamanda Adichie
    Carleen Brice
    Fledgling
    Junot Diaz
    Jude Dibia
    Petina Gappah
    Tayari Jones
    Jhumpa Lahiri
    Bernice McFadden
    Nnedi's Wahala Zone
    Sonia Sanchez
    Lori L. Tharps
    Alice Walker
    White Readers Meet Black Authors
    Saul Williams
    Jacqueline Woodson
    Read the Printed Word!

    Literary Reviews

    Arts & Letters Daily
    Belletrista
    Mythium Literary Magazine
    NPR Books
    NYT Book Review

    Culture

    The Black Culture Blog
    My American Melting Pot
    The Root
    Feminist Review
    Repeating Islands

    Picture

    Awards, Gotta Love 'Em!



    BrownGirl BookSpeak - Blogged
    Add to Technorati Favorites
    Books Blogs - Blog Catalog Blog Directory

    Blogs Her Color Button


    Top 21 Book Sites






    BBG Button


    indiebound



    Picture

© BrownGirl Speaks 2009 - 2011