BrownGirl Speaks
  • Home
  • blog
  • Books
  • About Me
  • Contact Me

How pop culture perpetuates violence against women

4/18/2011

0 Comments

 
In light of my last post on the badass female character type, I decided to share my response to a recent assignment for my Contemporary Women's Issues course...

With a resounding yes, I say that pop culture influences violence against women. Gruesome images of murdered female bodies may desensitize viewers to the violent acts that lead to those deaths. Often female victims are portrayed as immoral characters which further compounds the desensitization of the violence committed against them. Then, I think about the number of times I've seen a strong female character on screen raped. It's a sick reminder/warning that she needed to be put in her place and the only way to do so is to put her in a situation where she is physically without control. Brawn over brains it is. As our readings explains, abuse results from “internalized sexism and the right to dominate women” (Lee & Shaw, p. 569). This reminds me of one of my favorite shows and a recent story arc involving the rape of a female doctor. My initial reaction to Charlotte's rape was sorrow then joy as she triumphed in her recovery. Later, I realized that Private Practice had fallen into the formulaic routine of sensationalizing the immoral and the need to break down its strongest female character to show her humanity. Why does victimization equal humanity? Charlotte is hard edged woman and it seems now that this was a way to show that she's not just a cold, emasculating woman. Why is violence against a women used to portray the injection of a soul into her being?

A franchise that's thrived predominantly on its depictions of violence against women is Law & Order. It's even devoted one of its many spin offs to the real life special victims unit which specifically handles sex crimes. These we know that women are historically far more frequently the victim of than men. Again, when people can turn this series on daily as it's in syndication, it slowly but surely takes away the acrid sting of this form of violence and basically makes it seem not so bad. 

My husband and I got into a heated discussion several months ago when he was explaining to me the popularity of the rape/revenge film genre in the 70s. My one question was: "Who were these sick, twisted films created for?" Who do those movies' filmmakers consider their target audience? Surely not women. I refuse to believe that women were/are viewing those films and feeling empowered. Men? I can't imagine what men think. I did a quick web search and sure enough the story is that these films have been made to empower women. What's problematic about this is twofold. First, the rape itself is not condemned in this type of film. It's lazy filmmaking because the rape has to be played out for shock value. More importantly, what would empower women is initiatives that prevent from ever occurring not how to get revenge on the attacker. Second, that one act of violence is met with another only perpetuates a cycle of violence thus the system of patriarchy which for intents and purposes a system of domination. Dominating another person does not give one control. It's simply wasted energy and doesn't solve the problem systemically.

As I was doing a bit of web research on this question, I came across a great article by Natasha Walker for The Guardian. She wrote about the high amount of violence against women in movies noting her recent pre-screening of a film titled The Killer Inside Me. The film depicts at least two graphic murders of women. Walker states that in the Q & A with the film's director, Michael Winterbottom, she asked why was the violence so graphically depicted. His response was: “It's more moral to make it unwatchable” (Walker, 2010). I don't think viewers are more disgusted by violence against women. They're shocked for that moment but I think empirical evidence would probably show that this type of depiction has no lasting affect regarding activism or prevention or driving down the number of violent acts. It makes it more fabled if anything. 

Sources: 
Shaw, S. M., & Lee, J. (2009). Women's voices, feminist visions (4th ed.). Boston: Mcgraw-Hill Higher Education.

Walker, N. (2010, June 3). Why is there so much movie violence against women? | Natasha Walter | Film | The Guardian . Latest news, comment and reviews from the Guardian | guardian.co.uk . Retrieved April 17, 2011, from http://www.guardian.co.uk/film/2010/jun/03/women-violence-killer-inside-me-feminism


Now, I'm aware that I didn't address music and literature in this as it was to simply be a two page reflection. These were what came to mind immediately. I would like to hear some other clear examples, namely in literature, on this topic. One that I did intend to mention but forgot is Twilight. It's been noted that Bella's almost endeared reaction to the bruises unintentionally left on her body by her beloved Edward romanticizes domestic partner abuse. Yes, Edward is a vampire with superhuman strength and the slightest touch from him could leave a mark, however, it could warp the thinking of young girls who could find themselves in a truly abusive relationship. So, please do share your thoughts.
0 Comments

Brains and Brawn: The female badass in "Salt"

4/15/2011

2 Comments

 
The Mr. and I just watched Salt starring Angelina Jolie as a CIA agent/ Russian spy. About halfway through the film, he asked me if I felt this type of character was a positive role model for girls/women. Well of course it is! First, I have to note that after watching the extras, it appears Jolie handled many of the stunts herself and shortly after giving birth to twins. That's just badass in and of itself. Now, Evelyn Salt was not just a trained sleeper agent in the way men typically are which is basically as trained assassins. Salt used far more cunning than we usually see from either gender in action films.  For her, a gun was a last resort if she couldn't take you down with a good old fashioned beat down and, even then she only used it to wound her opposition. Flat out murder was saved for those absolutely deserving of it. I know, who deserves to die might be totally subjective, but watch the film to catch my drift. 

It's stated in the extras by the director, Phillip Noyce, that Jolie was offered the female lead in a Bond movie but instead proposed she have a Bond-like role created for her. So "Salt" was born. For a predominantly male run production, save the one female producer Sunil Perkash, this speaks volumes. Salt's badassness was never undermined or overshadowed by gratuitous nudity or even suggestive garb. Jolie's beauty (I know, again, subjective) was neither overplayed or underplayed.  Was this an award snubbed film? No. But it's such a big step in the right direction of the film industry when it comes to portrayals of women. Now we just need a woman of color given a shot at the same type of role sans a sexually suggestive name and nature.
2 Comments

Giveaway: handmade wire wrap bracelets

4/7/2011

 

Update: Congrats Miss Princess Dom! Since you were the only entrant I'm sending you BOTH bracelets. Enjoy!

I'm in a bracelet making mood and decided to share via this impromptu giveaway. I shared pics of one I made for myself yesterday and if you missed it, it's because you haven't become a facebook fan.
The bracelets up for grabs are below.  Just tweet the link to this post then leave me a comment with the link to your tweet. How to do that? Copy the link to that tweet via its time stamp in your twitter feed. Entries are unlimited. Open to U.S. residents only. This will be open today only until 11:59 pm CST and I'll announce the two winners tomorrow morning as an update to this post. I'll email the winners for an address so make sure you include an email in your comments/entries or I'll have to select someone else. Ah yes, be sure to mention your preference but know that I'll make an executive decision if both winners like the same bracelet. Bonne Chance!
    "Every valuable human being must be a radical and a rebel, for what he must aim at is to make things better than they are."
    --Niehls Bohr

    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    37
    Everyday Use
    Homeschool
    The Arts

    Archives

    July 2016
    January 2016
    September 2015
    August 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    June 2013
    January 2013
    April 2012
    November 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010


    Old Homeschool Posts
    Old Random Posts


© BrownGirl Speaks 2009 - 2015
  • Home
  • blog
  • Books
  • About Me
  • Contact Me