BrownGirl Speaks
  • Home
  • blog
  • Books
  • About Me
  • Contact Me

Book prizes: serious business or too much hype?

8/12/2009

 
On the heels of the Man Booker Prize longlist being released, The Guardian came up with their own award: The Not Booker Prize.  On some forums the chatter surrounding book prizes, especially Booker's, is that many of the shortlisted books, and the subsequent winner, may not be consistent with what most readers have raved about each year.

There are some who choose to follow the suggestive nature of book prizes like they are the omniscient authority on books. There are others, like myself, who take most book prizes with a grain of salt. In my case, the most well known prizes barely reflect my taste in literature enough for me to invest more than a few glances at the nominees and winners.

So, I ask my fellow bibliophiles: How much stock do you put into book prizes?

Karoline link
9/8/2009 04:19:54

Wed, 12 Aug 2009 14:22:53
Nada. Zip. Zilch.

Some I've read and I'm think: THIS won the award? WTF?

the reliable ones I tend to listen to are children's awards. I've read some of those and they've been excellent. It's the adult ones I'm weary of.
 

BrownGirl
9/8/2009 04:20:25

Wed, 12 Aug 2009 14:27:59
That's funny Karoline and so true. It's always some book that no one has read yet, but then it's a mad scramble, for some, to get it just b/c of the award. I'm on a different drumbeat too.

Jenna link
9/8/2009 04:21:44

Thu, 13 Aug 2009 15:40:48
Hi, I followed you over here from book blogs.

I probably put more stock into them then I necessarily should. But there is just something about a list that I feel like I need to accomplish, lol! If a book on a list doesn't sound interesting to me I won't read it. But if it does, then there's a good chance I'll want to read it.

I'm going to follow your blog... it looks good!

Jenna link
9/8/2009 04:22:49

Mon, 17 Aug 2009 18:45:36
I have an award for you <a href="http://takemeaway-jennala9.blogspot.com/"> here </a>

J.T. Oldfield link
9/8/2009 04:48:25

Wed, 05 Aug 2009 11:48:00
So far my favorite way to talk to other Book Bloggers has been Twitter. When other bloggers post reviews, I usually click on them. That's great because I follow more bloggers on Twitter than with my Google Reader!

Karoline link
9/8/2009 04:48:51

Wed, 05 Aug 2009 12:01:06
It's entirely up to you. I have accounts in ning groups, shelfari, goodreads, and librarything. I post my reviews on all of them. I think it somewhat maximizes exposure of the book. That's just my opinion though :)

Charley link
9/8/2009 04:49:44

Wed, 05 Aug 2009 19:04:56
I'm a writer rather than a reviewer, but I do belong to several writing and/or reading groups. I see very little overlap between the groups, but I think that's good because of the fresh viewpoints on each site or blog.

Charley

Nishita link
9/8/2009 04:50:31

Wed, 05 Aug 2009 20:51:57
I am a member of Shelfari and LibraryThing. However, I am afraid I am not that active on them.

I just post book reviews on my blog, and just add my favorite books to my shelf on Shelfari/LibraryThing. I then tweet about my review so folks following me get a look. I have recently become active on Book Blogs and I am enjoying the experience here so far.

I find it is just too much overhead for me to post things to so many different places.

Would be nice to have a tool that allows you to publish your review to multiple forums.

Terry Doherty link
9/8/2009 04:51:14

Sat, 08 Aug 2009 06:26:57
I have an account with LibraryThing that I haven't used since I discovered GoodReads. I just recently added a Shelfari account.

I don't have the patience nor time to add reviews to both accounts, and since I've been on Goodreads for more than 2 years, I'll continue to post there. That said, I've got all my books on Shelfari and I will keep it up to date with current reads. If you're thinking about widgets for your sidebar. I like Shelfari's MUCH better. That was a driving factor for adding the account. Since joining, I've been very impressed with their assistance and its timeliness. I asked them about importing reviews from GoodReads (since you can import your list of books) and they are looking at the idea.

I don't envision duplicating contacts or groups in Shelfari. I'm active in several groups on Goodreads and started a group on Shelfari that is distinct from my other stuff.

Cross-platform is helpful and it introduces me to folks who aren't *everywhere* so as long as I can keep the processes simple and the goals distinct, it is manageable to do both.


Comments are closed.
    Authors and publishers feel free to check out my review policy and contact me  regarding review requests.
    The Book Depository
    Picture

    My Amazon.com Wish List

    Picture

    Archives

    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010
    January 2010
    December 2009
    November 2009
    October 2009
    September 2009
    August 2009
    July 2009

    Categories

    All
    African Diaspora
    And The Word Was Spoken
    Asian Authors
    Author Interviews
    Banned Books
    Blog Tours
    Bookish
    Book Reviews
    Book Tours
    Challenges
    Diversity Roll Call
    Giveaways
    Guest Post
    Kid Lit
    Latino Authors
    Native American Authors
    Nonfiction
    Quirky Brown
    Reading Africa
    The Box Is Hot
    Women Writers
    Writing
    Ya Fiction


    Picture
    Sign Up
    Suggestion List
    First Quarter Reviews
    Second Quarter Reviews
    Third Quarter Reviews
    Read 17/12

    Picture
    Read 5/54
    Picture
    Read 5/8
    Read 2/5
    Picture
    Read 1/4
    2010 Social Justice Reading Challenge
    Read 0/12
    Picture
    Read 1/7
    Read 26/25

    Book Blogs

    A Striped Armchair
    Authors In Color
    Black Eyed Susans
    Book Blab
    Book On the Train
    Brown Paper
    Color Online
    For the Love of Books
    In Spring It Is The Dawn
    Kinna Reads
    Lotus Reads
    Love of Literature
    Notorious Spinks Talks
    Page247
    Reading In Color
    Reads4Pleasure
    Rhapsody In Books
    The Brown Bookshelf
    The Feminist Texican [Reads]
    The Happy Nappy Bookseller
    With Extra Pulp
    Worducopia

    Authors

    Chimamanda Adichie
    Carleen Brice
    Fledgling
    Junot Diaz
    Jude Dibia
    Petina Gappah
    Tayari Jones
    Jhumpa Lahiri
    Bernice McFadden
    Nnedi's Wahala Zone
    Sonia Sanchez
    Lori L. Tharps
    Alice Walker
    White Readers Meet Black Authors
    Saul Williams
    Jacqueline Woodson
    Read the Printed Word!

    Literary Reviews

    Arts & Letters Daily
    Belletrista
    Mythium Literary Magazine
    NPR Books
    NYT Book Review

    Culture

    The Black Culture Blog
    My American Melting Pot
    The Root
    Feminist Review
    Repeating Islands

    Picture

    Awards, Gotta Love 'Em!



    BrownGirl BookSpeak - Blogged
    Add to Technorati Favorites
    Books Blogs - Blog Catalog Blog Directory

    Blogs Her Color Button


    Top 21 Book Sites






    BBG Button


    indiebound



    Picture
© BrownGirl Speaks 2009 - 2015
  • Home
  • blog
  • Books
  • About Me
  • Contact Me